| Year | Name | Award |
| 2022 | Sam Adams | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2022 | Raphael Arias | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2021 | Zane Saab | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2016 | Robert Masters | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2014 | Brent Orbell | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2010 | Gianni Maruggi | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2008 | Max Smidinger | NSCAA Second Team All America |
| 2008 | Max Smidinger | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2007 | Justin Hovaker | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2006 | Pavel Raynov | NSCAA Second Team All America |
| 2006 | Pavel Raynov | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2005 | Zachary DiCarlo | NSCAA Second Team All America |
| 2005 | Zachary DiCarlo | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2004 | Ryan Kemp | NSCAA First Team All America |
| 2004 | Ryan Kemp | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2002 | Steve Abey | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1996 | James (Jack) Karl | NSCAA First Team All America |
| 1996 | James (Jack) Karl | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1995 | James (Jack) Karl | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1994 | Nick Badalian | NSCAA First Team All America |
| 1994 | Nick Badalian | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1993 | Nick Badalian | NSCAA Third Team All America |
| 1993 | Nick Badalian | NJCAA Third Team All America |
| 1992 | Jody Haislip | NSCAA Second Team All America |
| 1992 | Jody Haislip | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1991 | Jody Haislip | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1990 | Kevin Wise | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1989 | Chris Temple | NSCAA Third Team All America |
| 1980 | Pablo Marzin | NJCAA Honorable Mention All America |